The Hunt for a good Silicone Slotted Turner

Seeking the Perfect Silicone Slotted Turner

I’ve been on the lookout for a good silicone slotted turner for quite some time. Last year, I purchased a few items from Thermoworks and I’m thrilled with the quality—everything still looks brand new, and the silicone remains soft. I’d love to buy more from them, but they don’t carry a slotted turner!

What I’m after is a turner with high heat resistance, ideally up to 600°F, so I can confidently use it at 400°F without worries. The edge should be thin enough to slide under food easily, yet large enough to handle larger or oddly shaped items without being too unwieldy for small or crowded pans. A medium to long handle is a must as well. I want it to be flexible but still sturdy enough to avoid breaking. I know this is a tall order, which might explain why Thermoworks hasn’t produced one yet. Also, it needs to be in a sleek color—dark gray or black would blend seamlessly into any kitchen design!

I’m mainly jotting this down for my own reference and will share which one I decide to buy. If it turns out to be disappointing, I’ll update this post with my findings. Here are the options I’m considering:

1. GreenPan Platinum Silicone Slotted Turner
   The color is perfect, and it has a great long handle. But it looks a bit thick and inflexible, plus it’s only rated for 392°F, which doesn’t give me much leeway at the high end. It’s also pricey at $20 plus shipping!

2. Amazon 600°F Heat Resistant Silicone Turner
   This one has a thick scooping part and has received reviews saying it’s inflexible, which could make it tricky to use. It’s on the pricier side at $26, but since it’s on Amazon, returns shouldn’t be a hassle. Nice to see an option with a 600°F limit though!

3. Pampered Chef Silicone Slotted Turner
   Unfortunately, this model has a nylon handle, giving it an unattractive two-tone look that contrasts with my other tools. It has a decent temperature limit of 450°F, which offers some comfort for cooking on the higher end of medium. Priced at $17, it could be worth it if the quality is acceptable.

4. Tablecraft Professional Silicone Turner
   I’m eyeing the “wide slotted” option, which is affordably priced, but the short handle poses a safety risk—I’m concerned about splatters. Its temperature limit is 400°F.

5. Sur La Table Stainless Steel Silicone Edge Turner
   I’ve heard great things about their products, including their silicone-tipped fish turner. However, this model’s tip is a glaring red, clashing with my kitchen aesthetics and I’m not willing to pay $29 for it! Plus, the temperature limit isn’t specified, just “high-heat resistant,” which makes me a bit wary; I’d anticipate it to be around 392°F based on experience.

Ultimately, here’s the first turner I’m going to try:
Tablecraft H3905GY Silicone Heat Resistant Turner
It has a longer handle and a more traditional shape. While there aren’t any reviews yet, Amazon’s return policy means I can easily send it back if it’s not up to par. With a temperature limit of 400°F and a price of $15, it seems reasonable. The images on different sites show it as a lighter gray than advertised on Amazon, but I’ll have to see how it looks in person.